Some facets of renewable energy production, particularly the lithium-ion industry, can cause more harm than good.
Lithium mining in Nevada. Doc Searls. CC By 2.0.
The transition to renewable energy is typically viewed as a positive step toward a sustainable future. However, beneath the surface, the renewable energy industry presents a complex set of ethical and social challenges complicating its status as a completely “green” solution. While solar, wind and battery technologies offer a path away from fossil fuels, their production and implementation raise concerns regarding environmental degradation, social justice and economic equity.
One of the most significant ethical dilemmas in renewable energy revolves around the extraction of lithium, a key component in batteries used for electric vehicles and energy storage. While lithium-ion batteries enable the storage of solar and wind energy, the process of obtaining lithium has a devastating environmental impact. Extracting lithium from underground brine reservoirs requires vast amounts of water, exacerbating water scarcity in already arid regions such as the Atacama Desert in Chile. Additionally, chemical runoff from mining operations can create contamination in local ecosystems, posing a threat to biodiversity, agricultural livelihoods and local residents.
Beyond the environmental impact, lithium mining also has severe social implications. Many mining operations are located in Indigenous territories, where local communities have little say in the exploitation of their lands. Reports from Chile, Argentina and Bolivia highlight cases where Indigenous groups have been displaced or denied proper consultation before lithium extraction projects began on their land. As demand for lithium continues to rise with the demand for green energy, ensuring that mining operations adhere to ethical labor practices and environmental safeguards is essential to prevent further harm to affected communities.
In the U.S., projects like the Thacker Pass lithium mine in Nevada have sparked protests from Native American tribes who argue that these developments threaten sacred sites and traditional ways of life. Similar conflicts have emerged in Australia and Kenya, where Indigenous communities have been either removed from ancestral lands or forced to make way for renewable energy infrastructure.
While renewable energy is intended to benefit both the planet and society on a grand scale, the benefits are not always equitably distributed. Many large-scale projects are owned by corporations that prioritize profit over local interests, leading to conflicts over land rights and resource allocation. The challenge lies in ensuring that renewable energy expansion does not come at the cost of marginalized communities, but rather includes them in the decision-making process and offers them tangible benefits, like the shift in Australia to include First Nation people at the forefront of decisions regarding renewable energy.
The path to a future of sustainable energy is not simply about replacing fossil fuels but about doing so in a way that prioritizes social and environmental justice. By addressing these ethical challenges head-on, the renewable energy sector can move toward a truly sustainable model that benefits both people and the planet.
GET INVOLVED:
There are efforts within the industry to make renewable energy more ethical and sustainable. Organizations such as the Global Battery Alliance and the Union of Concerned Scientists are working to establish stricter environmental regulations for mining, promote recycling initiatives for battery materials and develop alternative energy storage solutions that reduce dependence on lithium. Other organizations like Redwood Materials look to make the lithium process more circular and less wasteful.
Zoe Lodge
Zoe is a student at the University of California, Berkeley, where she is studying English and Politics, Philosophy, & Law. She combines her passion for writing with her love for travel, interest in combatting climate change, and concern for social justice issues.